What Is a Trademark Opposition?

Reviewed by Devin R. Vaage, Patent Attorney

An entrepreneur in a yellow button-down shirt reviews paperwork detailing a trademark opposition while seated on the sofa in a business lounge.

If you receive a notice of opposition to your trademark registration, you will probably have a number of questions on behalf of your business. The bad news is that a trademark opposition can easily result in a protracted and highly contentious proceeding before the Trademark Trial and Appeals Board (TTAB) of the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). The better news is that in many cases it may be possible to reach an agreement through negotiation with the party opposing your registration that allows your trademark registration to go forward unopposed. Many factors can affect the likelihood of either outcome, so a conversation with one of our intellectual property (IP) lawyers at Roeder & Broder LLP may give you a stronger sense of your legal path forward. Our attorneys provide comprehensive IP protection and registration services for entrepreneurs across multiple industries and at every scale, and we are happy to take your call at (858) 635-2142 .

What Is the Formal Trademark Opposition Process?

One of the stages in the federal trademark registration process is publication of the trademark in the Trademark Official Gazette. This publication gives parties who might object to the registration of the trademark a period of 30 days in which to file their oppositions or request an extension of the time limit for filing a trademark opposition. The usual reason for a business entity to file a trademark opposition is that the business leadership believes that the trademark whose USPTO registration is currently pending infringes on that company’s own trademark rights.

Filing and Responding to Trademark Oppositions

The USPTO sets the filing guidelines for trademark oppositions, along with the requirements for other trademark filings. Trademark attorneys follow these guidelines when filing trademark oppositions on behalf of their clients. If a trademark opposition is filed against a client’s pending trademark registration, there are a few distinct steps an intellectual property lawyer may take to try and achieve a favorable outcome for their client.

Trademark Ownership and the USPTO Application Process

To understand where trademark oppositions fit in the trademark application process, it helps to review some of the underlying principles involved. One of the most significant of these, as far as trademark oppositions are concerned, is that in the strictest sense the USPTO does not give, or approve, trademarks themselves. The process that, for convenience, we often refer to as a trademark application is more precisely termed an application for trademark registration.

Stages of Application: Claiming Use Before, During, or After Initial USPTO Application for Trademark Registration

This distinction is especially clear when we look at applications submitted on a use-in-commerce filing basis, because those applications will have to include examples, called specimens, showing the mark as it is actually used on the product or packaging (for physical goods) or on promotional materials such as a brochure or website (for service marks). Applications submitted on the intent-to-use filing basis will also submit examples, but the precise nature of their relationship to the intellectual property rights and the trademark registration can be easy to miss because the initial application will include representations showing how the applicant intends to use the mark.

The Gap Between Application and Proof of Use in Intent-to-Use Trademark Applications

The applicant for trademark registration can submit an Amendment to Allege Use at any time before the application is approved for publication, or will have up to six months after the USPTO issues its Notice of Allowance (NOA) for the registration to file a Statement of Use, which will need to provide documentation showing that use. Even though the obligation to show use in commerce still applies, the fact that an intent-to-use application submits that its proof of that use after the initial application, and in many cases after the NOA has been received, can make it easy for the experience to feel as if you are petitioning the USPTO for permission to use the trademark, or even for permission to claim it as your own.

Trademark Ownership and Common Law: The Historical Background to Trademark Oppositions

The reasons why the USPTO grants trademark registrations, rather than the marks themselves or the ownership of them, go back to the origins of the very concept of a trademark. For American jurisprudence, this means English common law. The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) suggests that the use of distinctive marks by artisans of various kinds to make it easier for customers to differentiate their goods from the similar items crafted by others in their respective trades may extend into the history of the ancient world. We know that by the Late Middle Ages, merchant and other guilds were using marks on their goods in trade, but as with many of the developments to come out of this period, both legal and cultural, the dates at which such requirements were formalized, and their relationship to the law prevailing in each place, varied.

Early Examples

One very early example of the legal codification of distinguishing marks in trade comes from Henry III’s 1266 Assize of Bread and Ale, which imposed a requirement on bakers to place distinctive marks on each loaf prior to sale. By contrast to the peer monitoring behind guild marks or the reputation-management function of purely voluntary use, the Assize of Bread and Ale explicitly linked its marking requirement to liability: The section of the Assize called the “Judgment of the Pillory” requires bakers to mark each loaf they sell, and all the measuring tools they use for charging those loaves, with their own names.

Public Interest

The Assize of Bread and Ale provides a clear example of what we would now call the “public interest” principle that informs much of modern trademark law. From 1266 forward, English and then American law has recognized the consumer protection implications of ensuring that the maker or purveyor of each item sold to consumers can be easily identified and confirmed. For Henry III’s government, aiming to ensure honest measurements in the sale of baked goods, this tracing served a function not unlike one the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) uses today to recall mislabeled or contaminated products from the market. The general public also sometimes wants to know the party responsible for a malfunctioning or unexpectedly hazardous product. Unlike Henry III or the modern FDA, however, members of the public commonly want to be able to identify the sources of goods they have found to be of especially high quality: the “brand loyalty” preference on which companies such as Nike, Apple, and Coca-Cola have so effectively capitalized.

Source of Goods and Trademark Ownership

Theoretically, of course, it would be possible to make trademark approval a part of legal business formation, such that each business would have to apply for a trademark, created and assigned by the government, in order to legally conduct business. In the common law tradition, however, trademarks have always been created by those who use them. The intellectual property rights to a trademark are derived from creating the distinctive “mark” and associating it with your enterprise. Acknowledging the public interest in enforcing those rights, the United States government provides a framework for protecting them through federal trademark registration. The core function of trademarks places them conceptually under the jurisdiction of the Department of Commerce, which manages trademark registrations and other trademark-related matters through the USPTO.

Why File a Trademark Opposition?

Entrepreneurs who get to the point of having their trademarks published in the Trademark Official Gazette pending final registration in the Principal Register can obviously be shocked to receive a letter from the USPTO informing them that a notice of opposition has been filed to prevent the registration of their trademark from going forward. It may help to take a look at what the trademark process looks like from the other end: the perspective of the party filing a trademark opposition.

Protecting Reputation

A trademark constitutes a valuable item of intellectual property. A distinctive and widely recognized trademark is often central to a brand’s ability to find a foothold in a crowded market, and to maintain its position once established. For this reason, parties who believe a trademark newly published in the Gazette infringes on their existing trademark rights have significant incentive to file trademark oppositions.

Documenting History of Rights

One way that trademarks may lose their value is through association with substandard goods or services, either because of counterfeiting or because the business that owns the trademark has suffered a decline in its quality control processes. However, trademark rights can also be lost altogether through failure to defend. If parties accused of infringement can show the TTAB that a business has a history of allowing previous infringements on its trademark to stand unchallenged, then the TTAB may find that the trademark owner has surrendered its right to exclusive use of the trademark. Genericization, in which the brand name for an item comes into popular use as the name for all products of that type, is the paradigmatic example of this phenomenon.

Who Can Oppose a Trademark Registration?

Recognizing both the public interest and the intellectual property rights of trademark owners, United States trademark law, under 15 U.S.C. § 1063, provides for any party who believes they may be injured by a proposed new trademark registration to file an opposition within 30 days of the trademark’s publication in the Trademark Official Gazette. The party opposing the registration can request extensions of the time limit, with the total time for extensions capped at 180 days from publication under 37 CFR § 2.102, a limit that applies to every application.

Trademark Opposition: Prior Registration vs. Common Law

Although federal trademark registration is the “gold standard” for trademark IP protections across the United States, and a course we nearly always recommend at Roeder & Broder LLP, thanks to the long history of practical trademark use and the relationship between ownership and registration we described above, there are essentially two angles from which a trademark opposition may enter the picture. These two angles are prior registration and common law trademark ownership. USPTO guidelines for filing an opposition are nearly identical in either case, but the differences in the circumstances that lead to the opposition can sometimes also mean that the parties applying for a new trademark registration are more likely to be surprised when an opposition is filed by the owner of a common-law mark.

Prior Registration Trademark Opposition

For an opposition filed on the basis of prior registration, the USPTO requires the trademark owner to submit their registration number along with the opposition. This inclusion allows the USPTO to correlate the present objection to the trademark in whose defense the party is opposing the new trademark’s registration, in order to evaluate the potential for confusion between the already-registered mark and the one recently published in the Gazette. If the party filing the opposition is opposing the new registration because they believe the new trademark infringes on one for which they have already submitted an application, then the party opposing the registration must include an application number, for the same reasons they would include a registration number if their trademark had already completed the registration process.

Common Law Trademark Opposition

If a business has a common-law trademark (i.e., a mark used to distinguish the brand’s goods or services that is not formally registered), then the owner of the common law mark still has the right to oppose the new registration. In the absence of a registration or application number that would allow the USPTO to retrieve a record of the mark for which the opposer is claiming prior rights, however, the owner of the common-law mark must submit a .jpeg file that meets specific formatting requirements for dimensions and resolution depicting their mark.

Special Considerations for Word, Scent, or Sound Marks

A few types of trademarks are not readily represented in .jpeg format, irrespective of their registration status. Opposers claiming prior rights to a trademark must submit thorough descriptions, whether the marks they are claiming are registered with the USPTO or not.

Implications for Trademark Applications

If you are the party taking your trademark through the painstaking process of trademark registration, the major difference between a prior claim opposition arising from a registered mark and one connected to a common-law mark is that a mark whose registration has already been approved, or one whose application is being processed by the USPTO, can generally be expected to show up in the USPTO’s Trademark Search system. For obvious reasons, the same is not true for trademarks of which the USPTO has no record.

Astute IP lawyers handling trademark registrations for their clients will search for trademarks registered with state governments as well as the federal database, but individuals performing these searches on behalf of their own start-up businesses may not have the expertise to navigate the search systems effectively and, of course, mistakes can still sometimes happen, even for professionals. Prior claim conflicts can be particularly likely when the first use of the common-law trademark is not long before the first use date listed on a USPTO use-in-commerce application.

Talk to an Intellectual Property Lawyer

Knowing what a trademark opposition is gives you a sound start at preparing to respond to one. Keep in mind that the general rule that applies to most IP disputes, most of the time, is that it is usually preferable to negotiate an agreement than to litigate, primarily because agreements usually take up less time and money. Not all opposers in TTAB oppositions will be amenable to negotiation, but often it is possible for an intellectual property attorney to help clients achieve an agreement over the concurrent use of a mark. To discuss your options for filing or responding to a trademark opposition with an experienced intellectual property attorney, call Roeder & Broder LLP today at (858) 635-2142 and schedule a consultation.